Home · Faith · Nov 20 archive
US Bishops Raise Concerns Over ICE Detainees and Assisted Suicide Laws
Confirmed
In Short: During the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops' fall plenary assembly in Baltimore, Nov. 16-19, bishops highlighted key religious liberty issues, including access to sacraments for ICE detainees and the risks posed by state laws legalizing physician-assisted suicide.

Archbishop Hicks emphasized the church's long-standing commitment to ministering to incarcerated individuals, stating, 'The church has always had a ministry to those who were incarcerated.' He added, 'These are our own parishioners,' referring to ICE detainees.
Archbishop Hicks also criticized laws that force healthcare providers to consider assisted suicide as an option for terminally ill patients, calling it 'unconscionable and unconstitutional.' He noted, 'If you have a group of religious sisters who are committed to the compassionate care of people, especially when they’re coming to the end of their life, and then they’re being forced to have these people consider suicide as an option for ending their life, for us as Catholics, but I think also as a society, that shouldn’t only be unconscionable. It’s unconstitutional.'
The Archdiocese of St. Louis recently filed a lawsuit against the federal government over a policy it said prohibits priests from distributing Communion to and hearing confessions of ICE detainees. The archdiocese argued, 'This is a little bit of a different reality,' highlighting the unique challenges faced by religious entities.
In Illinois, a federal judge has temporarily blocked the state from forcing Catholic entities to aid in physician-assisted suicide, but the effort to make the block permanent continues.
Archbishop Hicks also addressed the broader cultural impact of assisted suicide laws, noting, 'It’s the broader effect that that has had, and a chilling effect, really, on the culture, just the very sacredness of life, the dignity of human life, especially for the elderly.'
Archbishop Hicks further stated, 'It isn’t just it isn’t just a matter of those who avail themselves of suicide through the assistance of physicians,' emphasizing the wider implications of such laws.
What this adds
The concerns raised by the bishops reflect a broader debate over religious liberty and the rights of religious entities to provide care according to their beliefs.
The bishops' statements highlight the intersection of religious freedom and public health policies, particularly in the context of immigration and end-of-life care.
What's confirmed
- Archbishop Hicks emphasized the church's long-standing commitment to ministering to incarcerated individuals, stating, 'The church has always had a ministry to those who were incarcerated.' He added, 'These are our own parishioners,' referring to ICE detainees.
- The Archdiocese of St. Louis recently filed a lawsuit against the federal government over a policy it said prohibits priests from distributing Communion to and hearing confessions of ICE detainees. The archdiocese argued, 'This is a little bit of a different reality,' highlighting the unique challenges faced by religious entities.
- In Illinois, a federal judge has temporarily blocked the state from forcing Catholic entities to aid in physician-assisted suicide, but the effort to make the block permanent continues.
- Archbishop Hicks further stated, 'It isn’t just it isn’t just a matter of those who avail themselves of suicide through the assistance of physicians,' emphasizing the wider implications of such laws.
What's still developing
- BALTIMORE (OSV News) — Access to sacraments for people detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and concerns posed by state laws legalizing physician-assisted suicide are among the key religious liberty concerns facing the U.S. Church, bishops told OSV News in interviews at the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ fall plenary assembly in Baltimore, held Nov. 16-19.
- Saporito currently serves as an auxiliary bishop in the Archdiocese of Newark and has spent more than three decades in ministry throughout North Jersey.
