Home · Health · Nov 19 archive
Study Reveals Gaps in Measuring Patient Experience
Confirmed
In Short: A new study highlights inconsistencies in how hospitals measure patient satisfaction and experience.
A recent study published in Hospital Pharmacy Europe has identified significant gaps in how hospitals measure patient experience, emphasizing the importance of structured measures and validated patient-reported experience measures (PREMs).
The study, which reviewed 4000 patient experiences across 11 hospitals in Spain, found that trust, accessibility, and continuity of care were key themes in patient experiences of pharmacist-led ambulatory services. Accessibility was mentioned in 14 studies, indicating its influence on patients' engagement with care.
However, the study noted that patient experience was rarely defined in advance and was predominantly captured through interviews and focus groups, rather than structured measures. Only two studies explicitly defined patient experience, and only two used validated PREMs.
One of the risks of traditional evaluation systems, according to the study, is that they rely on an overall assessment and do not examine specific, actionable aspects of the experience in sufficient depth. Aspects such as information and communication, participation in decision-making, accessibility, treatment, privacy, pain management, specific support needs, and continuity of care can provide relevant information.
The study also highlighted the importance of asking about specific dimensions and listening to patients to identify issues that questionnaires designed solely by professionals might not adequately capture. This distinction matters because it provides much more specific information for identifying tangible problems that hospitals can address.
In a separate report, the Lown Institute identified fifteen U.S. Cities with racially segregated hospital markets, where 50% or more of hospitals overserve or underserve Medicare patients from communities of color. The report found that hospitals serving the greatest proportion of Black Medicare patients received $477 less in patient care revenues per inpatient day on average compared to other hospitals.
Hospitals serving the most Black patients actually lost an average of $17 per inpatient day in profits while other hospitals gained $126 in profits each day. This financial disadvantage may explain some of the differences in quality of care.
The Lown Institute report noted that differences in insurance status play a role in the financial disadvantage for Black-serving hospitals, and that many of the most inclusive hospitals for Black patients are under-resourced, which can lead to poorer quality of care.
The study's findings underscore the need for hospitals to adopt more structured and validated measures to accurately assess patient experience and address specific issues that arise.
What this adds
The study adds to the understanding of how patient experience is measured and highlights the need for more structured and validated measures.
What's confirmed
- A recent study published in Hospital Pharmacy Europe has identified significant gaps in how hospitals measure patient experience, emphasizing the importance of structured measures and validated patient-reported experience measures (PREMs).
- The study, which reviewed 4000 patient experiences across 11 hospitals in Spain, found that trust, accessibility, and continuity of care were key themes in patient experiences of pharmacist-led ambulatory services. Accessibility was mentioned in 14 studies, indicating its influence on patients' engagement with care.
- However, the study noted that patient experience was rarely defined in advance and was predominantly captured through interviews and focus groups, rather than structured measures. Only two studies explicitly defined patient experience, and only two used validated PREMs.
- One of the risks of traditional evaluation systems, according to the study, is that they rely on an overall assessment and do not examine specific, actionable aspects of the experience in sufficient depth. Aspects such as information and communication, participation in decision-making, accessibility, treatment, privacy, pain management, specific support needs, and continuity of care can provide relevant information.
- The study also highlighted the importance of asking about specific dimensions and listening to patients to identify issues that questionnaires designed solely by professionals might not adequately capture. This distinction matters because it provides much more specific information for identifying tangible problems that hospitals can address.
- In a separate report, the Lown Institute identified fifteen U.S. Cities with racially segregated hospital markets, where 50% or more of hospitals overserve or underserve Medicare patients from communities of color. The report found that hospitals serving the greatest proportion of Black Medicare patients received $477 less in patient care revenues per inpatient day on average compared to other hospitals.
- Hospitals serving the most Black patients actually lost an average of $17 per inpatient day in profits while other hospitals gained $126 in profits each day. This financial disadvantage may explain some of the differences in quality of care.
- The Lown Institute report noted that differences in insurance status play a role in the financial disadvantage for Black-serving hospitals, and that many of the most inclusive hospitals for Black patients are under-resourced, which can lead to poorer quality of care.
- The study's findings underscore the need for hospitals to adopt more structured and validated measures to accurately assess patient experience and address specific issues that arise.
What's still developing
- Accessibility appeared in 14 studies and related to how the availability and organisation of services influenced patients’ abilities and willingness to engage with care.
- See the full list at the Lown Hospitals Index website.
