Home · Faith · Nov 18 archive
Why ‘St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy’ Could Mark a Huge Win for Religious Freedom
· Confirmed
In Short: The U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, a case that could reshape religious freedom protections.
The U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, a case that could overturn nearly 40 years of precedent regarding religious freedom and public benefits.
Colorado disagreed with the Archdiocese of Denver's request for an exemption from a nondiscrimination rule in the state’s universal preschool program, which prohibits participating schools from refusing admission based on sexual orientation or gender identity.
Justice Samuel Alito highlighted recent decisions at the intersection of religious freedom and LGBTQ rights, suggesting these precedents support the parish’s exemption request.
Justice Neil Gorsuch pondered whether the Smith precedent has already been effectively annulled via federal and state renditions of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.
Some private religious providers objected to the requirement, arguing that enrolling children of same-sex couples could upset the religious environment of their schools.
The justices' questions indicated the court may deliver more robust protections for religious exercise while potentially discarding the nearly four-decade-old precedent.
Colorado argued that Catholic preschools violated a nondiscrimination rule by only enrolling families that align with the Catholic Church's teachings.
The Archdiocese of Denver sought an exemption from the nondiscrimination rule when Colorado was preparing to implement the program.
In 2020, the Supreme Court ruled in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue that if a state provides funding for private schools, it cannot deny religious schools.
Oklahoma officials are supporting religious liberty and school choice in the case, while Colorado has lost similar cases before the high court.
Lambda Legal argued that when the state pays schools to provide preschool programming, the schoolhouse door must be open to every family.
The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) argued in an amicus brief that the government may not deny religious entities the right to participate in an otherwise generally available public program because of their religious character or exercise.
What's confirmed
- When Colorado was preparing to implement the program, the Archdiocese of Denver, which oversees 34 Catholic preschools, sought an exemption from the nondiscrimination rule, since they only enroll families that align with the Catholic Church's teachings, including on marriage, family and sexual identity.
- The Supreme Court on Tuesday will hear arguments in a case centered around religious liberty and whether Colorado can exempt Christian organizations from a statewide universal preschool program.
- Story Title: Supreme Court to hear case on religious freedom and Colorado’s universal preschool program The U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments on Tuesday in a case questioning whether religious schools that receive taxpayer funding can deny admittance to children of parents who are gay or transgender, NPR reported.
What's still developing
- Supreme Court Building on October 05, 2026 in Washington, DC.
- He noted that the laws in other cases involving public benefits had been neutral, rather than discriminating against religious people or organizations – for example, the court’s 1963 decision in Sherbert v.
- The petitioners are asking the Court to change how it reviews religious challenges to conditions on public funding.
- Decisions in recent years have shifted the education landscape on issues like publicly funded religious schools and transgender student athlete bans, and the high court is set to take up at least two key cases impacting K-12.
- The justices in April agreed to hear arguments in the case after two Catholic parishes challenged the state’s decision to ban them from the universal preschool program, which includes 15 hours of free classroom instruction each week.
- In the 2022 case Carson v. Makin, the Supreme Court ruled that religious schools can’t be kept from publicly funded programs if private, secular schools also have access.
- “In fact, letting Catholic schools in will create more seats for everyone, even for families who disagree with Catholic teachings.” Colorado’s actions were at the center of religious freedom disputes before the high court in 2018, 2023, and earlier this year, losing each case.
- I wrote my dissertation on the tensions between conservative religious teachings on gender and sexuality and LGBTQ+ experiences in Catholic schools — with implications that extend to policy and law.
