Home · Faith · Oct 6 archive
Federal Judge Rejects Oakland Diocese Bankruptcy Plan
Confirmed
In Short: A federal judge has rejected the Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland's bankruptcy plan, a decision that both parties described as disappointing.
Judge William Lafferty ruled that the diocese had not met the statutory requirements to settle its bankruptcy proceedings and dismissed claims that the diocese should receive special religious dispensation.
In his Oct. 2 decision, Lafferty stated that the diocese had failed to demonstrate a 'substantial burden' on its religious rights by being required to adhere to federal bankruptcy proceedings.
The judge also dismissed the diocese's argument that it should be treated differently due to its religious status, emphasizing that it should not be granted special protections.
The diocese had proposed a plan to pay over $200 million into an abuse victims' fund, but a committee of survivors countered with a proposed payout of more than $300 million.
The committee argued that the diocese had underestimated the value of its assets, including churches, cemeteries, and other properties across the East Bay.
Lafferty also questioned the diocese's financial figures, including the estimated value of its real estate assets and the total amount it expects to owe sexual abuse survivors.
Bishop Michael Barber, SJ, described the decision as 'a setback' but reaffirmed the diocese's commitment to providing fair and equitable treatment for abuse victims.
The diocese filed for bankruptcy in 2023 after more than 330 people filed claims against the church for allegations of abuse dating back to the 1960s.
The judge urged the diocese and abuse victims to continue dialogue and operate with 'relentless good faith' as they move forward.
Barber said the diocese would 'study the court’s decision' before deciding how to proceed.
What this adds
The judge's ruling adds to the ongoing legal challenges faced by the diocese, which has been in the news for a massive $16 million civil abuse suit earlier this year.
The diocese had previously announced plans to close 13 churches across the East Bay due to financial strain from the lawsuits.
Background
The Supreme Court, with no dissents, upheld a state court order requiring Missouri to use the 2022 election map, which favors Republicans in six of the eight districts but preserves a key seat for Democrats.
What's confirmed
- Judge William Lafferty ruled that the diocese had not met the statutory requirements to settle its bankruptcy proceedings and dismissed claims that the diocese should receive special religious dispensation.
- In his Oct. 2 decision, Lafferty stated that the diocese had failed to demonstrate a 'substantial burden' on its religious rights by being required to adhere to federal bankruptcy proceedings.
- The judge also dismissed the diocese's argument that it should be treated differently due to its religious status, emphasizing that it should not be granted special protections.
- The diocese had proposed a plan to pay over $200 million into an abuse victims' fund, but a committee of survivors countered with a proposed payout of more than $300 million.
- The committee argued that the diocese had underestimated the value of its assets, including churches, cemeteries, and other properties across the East Bay.
- Lafferty also questioned the diocese's financial figures, including the estimated value of its real estate assets and the total amount it expects to owe sexual abuse survivors.
- Bishop Michael Barber, SJ, described the decision as 'a setback' but reaffirmed the diocese's commitment to providing fair and equitable treatment for abuse victims.
- The diocese filed for bankruptcy in 2023 after more than 330 people filed claims against the church for allegations of abuse dating back to the 1960s.
- The judge urged the diocese and abuse victims to continue dialogue and operate with 'relentless good faith' as they move forward.
- Barber said the diocese would 'study the court’s decision' before deciding how to proceed.
What's still developing
- The federal judge admitted that the ruling was “not a happy result” for anyone involved in the trial, including for abuse victims, who he said have been “deeply … immersed” in the trial since 2023.
- The diocese, meanwhile, “has prosecuted this case honorably and with great integrity,” he said.
- “There is no guarantee of success in such endeavors, but also no reason not to begin again,” he said.
- The diocese was in the news earlier this year after a California man was awarded a massive $16 million in a civil abuse suit there.
- “This is not a happy result, to be sure, for any of the parties, or their counsel who have been deeply — and as they might well occasionally have imagined, perpetually — immersed in this case for now over three and a half years,” Lafferty wrote in the decision.
- Earlier this year, the diocese announced that it would close 13 churches across the East Bay, citing financial strain from the lawsuits.
- “For over three years, the Bishop and his … bankruptcy lawyers have deployed hardball tactics to further oppress and suppress justice, truth and transparency that the survivors seek through the creditors committee,” Anderson said.
- Jeff Anderson, a lawyer for survivors, celebrated Lafferty’s rejection of the diocese’s bankruptcy plan as a win in a statement Sunday.