Home · Sports · Oct 4 archive

Kirk Herbstreit Was Only ‘College GameDay’ Host to Correctly Predict This Upset

Confirmed

Sports Desk

In Short: Herbstreit's prediction came true as Minnesota defeated Michigan 20-14, marking the first time he correctly predicted an upset on the show.

2009-0912-OSU-KirkHerbstreit
Photo: Bobak Ha'Eri / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0)

WNBA star Caitlin Clark made her debut as a celebrity guest picker on ESPN's College GameDay on Saturday, October 3, 2026, joining a select group of women's basketball stars to participate in the show.

Clark was one of five pickers who predicted No. 4 Miami would defeat Clemson, and she was the only one to pick Mississippi State over Alabama.

YouTube — ESPN College Football YouTube

Kirk Herbstreit, one of the hosts, went against the grain for the Minnesota-Michigan game, predicting an upset.

Herbstreit also discussed his thoughts on the upcoming Notre Dame-BYU game, expressing his support for Notre Dame.

The fact that Herbstreit correctly predicted the upset is notable given his usual role as a commentator rather than a predictor.

What's confirmed

What's still developing

Sources