Home · Faith · Sep 30 archive
What Changes When the Audience Is Jewish
Confirmed
In Short: Vice President JD Vance's speech at the Republican Jewish Coalition's summit aimed to ease concerns about his support for the U.S.-Israeli relationship.
Vice President JD Vance's closed-door speech at the Republican Jewish Coalition’s annual leadership summit on Monday night aimed to alleviate top pro-Israel donors’ concerns about his commitment to the U.S.-Israeli relationship.
Shabbos Kestenbaum, a pro-Israel campus activist who spoke at the Republican National Convention in 2024, expressed disappointment in Vance’s answer to a question about Carlson, suggesting it could make it harder for Jewish conservatives to consider Vance’s candidacy.
Vance has faced skepticism from Jewish Republicans who question his stance on antisemitism within the GOP and his support for the U.S.-Israeli relationship.
Macklemore’s comments, which included calls for Palestinian freedom and criticism of Israel’s actions in Gaza, drew cheers from some but angered Israeli concertgoers and Jewish American groups.
Pink, a Jewish singer, addressed the backlash she faced for criticizing Macklemore, saying she was expressing her fear as a Jewish mother.
The rapper’s comments and performances have been criticized by Jewish groups, highlighting the complex dynamics around criticism of Israel and support for Palestinians.
In a separate development, a Jewish charter school in Oklahoma scored a key victory in its federal lawsuit seeking access to the state’s publicly funded charter program.
It remains unclear if this dispute will affect the status of Catholic charter schools.
These events underscore the ongoing tensions and debates within the Jewish community and among Jewish Republicans regarding support for Israel and broader political issues.
What this adds
The Jewish charter school victory and its potential impact on Catholic charter schools are unrelated to Vance's speech but highlight broader issues in education funding.
What's confirmed
- Vice President JD Vance's closed-door speech at the Republican Jewish Coalition’s annual leadership summit on Monday night aimed to alleviate top pro-Israel donors’ concerns about his commitment to the U.S.-Israeli relationship.
- Shabbos Kestenbaum, a pro-Israel campus activist who spoke at the Republican National Convention in 2024, expressed disappointment in Vance’s answer to a question about Carlson, suggesting it could make it harder for Jewish conservatives to consider Vance’s candidacy.
- Vance has faced skepticism from Jewish Republicans who question his stance on antisemitism within the GOP and his support for the U.S.-Israeli relationship.
- Macklemore’s comments, which included calls for Palestinian freedom and criticism of Israel’s actions in Gaza, drew cheers from some but angered Israeli concertgoers and Jewish American groups.
- Pink, a Jewish singer, addressed the backlash she faced for criticizing Macklemore, saying she was expressing her fear as a Jewish mother.
- The rapper’s comments and performances have been criticized by Jewish groups, highlighting the complex dynamics around criticism of Israel and support for Palestinians.
- In a separate development, a Jewish charter school in Oklahoma scored a key victory in its federal lawsuit seeking access to the state’s publicly funded charter program.
- It remains unclear if this dispute will affect the status of Catholic charter schools.
- These events underscore the ongoing tensions and debates within the Jewish community and among Jewish Republicans regarding support for Israel and broader political issues.
What's still developing
- But some attendees still have questions for Vance — particularly around his relationship with conservative pundit Tucker Carlson, who has long drawn ire from the Republican Jewish leaders for his criticism of Israel and outraged many when he hosted the antisemite Nick Fuentes for a lengthy podcast interview last year.
- Rapper Macklemore’s anti-Israel rant onstage at MetLife Stadium in New Jersey got him booted from singer Ed Sheeran’s tour — and he responded by blaming a Jewish man.
- Macklemore released a lengthy statement on Monday via Instagram, doubling down on his anti-Israel stance and then claiming that New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft — who is Jewish — was behind a concerted effort to get him removed from the tour.
- We have careers, money, opportunities, safety and audiences around the world.
- Pink, who is Jewish, said she wanted to be able to express her fear without being accused of supporting the war in Gaza.
- “To all of my Jewish brothers and sisters: criticism of Israel, criticism of apartheid, being against genocide in no way is a criticism of you,” he said.
- Know the news with the 7NEWS app: Download today Arrow The rapper has also used his performances to criticise Israel’s actions in Gaza and urge audiences to support Palestinians.
- “What I need is to be able to say, as a Jewish mom, ‘that scared me, and it scared people I love’, without being told our fear is just propaganda, and without being told I’m somehow cool with genocide because I noticed?” The singer also reiterated her position on the Israel-Gaza conflict, saying Hamas is a terrorist organisation while Palestinians deserve a future that respects their humanity.
- He was criticised by Jewish groups after making pro-Palestine political speeches ahead of his set.
- He told the audience, "A big part of the reason why I wanted to do this tour in the first place is so that I could stand up in stadiums like this and say two words that are very, very dear to my heart: Free Palestine." He then performed his song Hind's Hall, which condemns Israel's military action in Gaza, while video footage of the devastation in Gaza was shown on the big screen.
- The next night, Macklemore returned to the same stage and directly addressed his "Jewish brothers and sisters" in the audience.
- American rapper Macklemore called out “Free Palestine” during his opening set for Ed Sheeran at New Jersey’s MetLife Stadium on Friday night, drawing cheers from parts of the crowd and angry reactions from Israeli concertgoers and a Jewish American group.