Home · Sports · Sep 24 archive

Judge Rejects Request to Seal Records in Josh Jacobs Case

Confirmed

Sports Desk

In Short: Instead, the Hobart-Lawrence Police Department will handle any new requests made under public records laws.

Judge seals video, records in Josh Jacobs' case after plea deal
YouTube — WISN 12 News

The denial came after the victim's attorneys filed a motion seeking to seal evidence in the case on Tuesday, September 15, citing privacy rights under Marsy's Law.

The judge's order, effective between Thursday and Friday, cancels a temporary sealing order he issued on September 10.

YouTube — WISN 12 News YouTube

The denial does not immediately release the evidence, which includes surveillance video of the incident that took place in Jacobs' garage.

Instead, the Hobart-Lawrence Police Department will handle any new requests made under public records laws.

ESPN and several media outlets previously filed requests for evidence in the case, and those requests must now be resubmitted once the seal is lifted.

The victim's attorneys said the judge rejected the order due to a formatting error and have resubmitted a motion to seal.

According to the criminal complaint, Jacobs threw the woman, identified as 'ANM,' to the ground and damaged her phone.

Prosecutors said the incident began with an argument that ended with Jacobs throwing the victim to the ground.

Jacobs was placed on the NFL's commissioner exempt list on August 10, and a permanent sealing of evidence could have prevented the NFL from reviewing the video from the May 23 incident.

The Hobart-Lawrence Police Department has 10 days to respond to each public records request and must provide a valid reason under state laws if it denies access.

If the police department decides to release the evidence, the victim or Jacobs will be entitled to appeal before anything is released.

What this adds

The denial of the permanent sealing request could delay a potential decision from the NFL on Jacobs' status.

What's confirmed

What's still developing

Sources