Home · Faith · Sep 24 archive
How popes have faced France’s brand of Church-State separation
Confirmed
In Short: Pope Pius X initially opposed France's separation of Church and State, but later popes adopted a more conciliatory stance.
In 1906, Pope Pius X expressed deep suspicion towards France's secularism, which was established after the French Revolution.
After World War I, the Vatican's approach towards French secularism became more conciliatory, as relations between France and the Holy See were re-established.
Less than two months before his death, Pope John Paul II wrote a letter to the bishops of France, marking the centenary of the country’s law of separation between Church and State.
Over the decades, the tone and words used by popes regarding French secularism have changed significantly.
The popes have gradually recognized French secularism as a legitimate framework, provided it guarantees religious freedom and does not become hostile to religion.
What's confirmed
- In 1906, Pope Pius X expressed deep suspicion towards France's secularism, which was established after the French Revolution.
- After World War I, the Vatican's approach towards French secularism became more conciliatory, as relations between France and the Holy See were re-established.
- Less than two months before his death, Pope John Paul II wrote a letter to the bishops of France, marking the centenary of the country’s law of separation between Church and State.
- Over the decades, the tone and words used by popes regarding French secularism have changed significantly.
- The popes have gradually recognized French secularism as a legitimate framework, provided it guarantees religious freedom and does not become hostile to religion.
What's still developing
- Credit: Laurent Caron / Hans Lucas via AFP The Vatican once viewed France’s total separation of Church and State with deep suspicion.
- This document marked the papacy’s absolute opposition to the new regime of secularism instituted by the Third Republic in France.
- A Vatican source who has served under several pontificates says that the popes and those who work closely with them have never had a “monolithic” view of French secularism.
- Throughout her career, Stockard Channing has played some of pop culture’s most memorable characters: Betty Rizzo in Grease, First Lady Abigail Bartlet in The West Wing and Aunt Frances "Franny" Owens in Practical Magic.