Home · Business · Sep 15 archive
The AI data center boom is colliding with cities scarred by big industry
Confirmed
In Short: The AI data center boom is colliding with cities scarred by big industry, as water resilience becomes a critical consideration.
The AI data center boom is colliding with cities scarred by big industry, particularly as water resilience becomes a critical consideration. A recent dispute over Imperial Valley Computer Manufacturing’s proposed 330 MW AI data center in California highlights this challenge. The case underscores a broader question facing the data center industry: during a severe heatwave, when cooling demand surges and local water resources are already under pressure, what matters is not simply how much water a facility consumes on average, but whether it can continue operating reliably without exacerbating local water stress.
Water resilience is becoming as important a consideration as energy efficiency, yet it remains far less rigorously assessed. A data center may report an excellent Water Use Effectiveness (WUE) or advertise a “waterless” cooling strategy, but these metrics do not necessarily reflect the facility's ability to operate reliably during critical times. This challenge is compounded by the recent string of security-related incidents involving AI agents and a high-profile resignation, which has led AI industry leaders to slow down the pace of development to ensure safety.
The pushback is not unique to Philadelphia. Across the United States, residents are pushing back against new data center construction. In the first quarter of 2026, local opposition led to the disruption of at least 75 projects worth approximately $130 billion, according to Data Center Watch. This trend is prompting data center companies and their customers to promise new jobs and economic growth, but these promises have not won over a majority of Americans who oppose data center construction in their area.
In response, some states are taking a more cautious approach. At the Republican National Convention in Dallas, several Republican state party chairs told Newsweek they support developing data centers, but the process must include local control. Scott Golden, the chair of the Tennessee Republican Party, told Newsweek there are "legitimate issues on both sides" of the data center debate. He said data centers should be working toward development in places "where they make sense" and in states that want them. Florida offers a model for how states can approach the data center issue, Evan Power, the chair of the Florida Republican Party, told Newsweek. While there can be cases where there are legitimate concerns, he said, there are also benefits to data centers around energy issues.
Meanwhile, some regions are looking to capitalize on the data center boom. Poland's Green Capital has already leased land in Chubut for wind and solar that could supply energy to data centers, and the U.S.-based firm FlexDomes is looking for data center investors in Patagonia. The American public is increasingly skeptical of data centers, but the industry remains optimistic about finding new locations that can meet both their energy and water needs.
What's confirmed
- The AI data center boom is colliding with cities scarred by big industry, particularly as water resilience becomes a critical consideration. A recent dispute over Imperial Valley Computer Manufacturing’s proposed 330 MW AI data center in California highlights this challenge. The case underscores a broader question facing the data center industry: during a severe heatwave, when cooling demand surges and local water resources are already under pressure, what matters is not simply how much water a facility consumes on average, but whether it can continue operating reliably without exacerbating local water stress.
- Water resilience is becoming as important a consideration as energy efficiency, yet it remains far less rigorously assessed. A data center may report an excellent Water Use Effectiveness (WUE) or advertise a “waterless” cooling strategy, but these metrics do not necessarily reflect the facility's ability to operate reliably during critical times. This challenge is compounded by the recent string of security-related incidents involving AI agents and a high-profile resignation, which has led AI industry leaders to slow down the pace of development to ensure safety.
- The pushback is not unique to Philadelphia. Across the United States, residents are pushing back against new data center construction. In the first quarter of 2026, local opposition led to the disruption of at least 75 projects worth approximately $130 billion, according to Data Center Watch. This trend is prompting data center companies and their customers to promise new jobs and economic growth, but these promises have not won over a majority of Americans who oppose data center construction in their area.
- In response, some states are taking a more cautious approach. At the Republican National Convention in Dallas, several Republican state party chairs told Newsweek they support developing data centers, but the process must include local control. Scott Golden, the chair of the Tennessee Republican Party, told Newsweek there are "legitimate issues on both sides" of the data center debate. He said data centers should be working toward development in places "where they make sense" and in states that want them. Florida offers a model for how states can approach the data center issue, Evan Power, the chair of the Florida Republican Party, told Newsweek. While there can be cases where there are legitimate concerns, he said, there are also benefits to data centers around energy issues.
- Meanwhile, some regions are looking to capitalize on the data center boom. Poland's Green Capital has already leased land in Chubut for wind and solar that could supply energy to data centers, and the U.S.-based firm FlexDomes is looking for data center investors in Patagonia. The American public is increasingly skeptical of data centers, but the industry remains optimistic about finding new locations that can meet both their energy and water needs.
What's still developing
- After that post went up online, there was this rapid and extraordinary display of unity from other industry leaders.
- Disrupt 2026: OpenAI, Anthropic, Replit, and more take over 6 industry stages. 25% off tickets now Back by popular demand: Save up to $300 on Disrupt Across the country, Americans are debating how their lives might change if new AI data centers are built in their backyards.
- “We don’t want data centers,” Philly Thrive board president Sonya Sanders said at a rally on Monday at Philadelphia’s City Hall.
- “A typical data center planned in Pennsylvania has hundreds of diesel engines that spew air pollution, and even if they’re supposedly reserved for emergencies, the government has already said that the data center should use those rather than drawing from an overstressed electrical grid during some heat waves,” said Clean Air Council attorney Annie Fox at the rally.
- “From that point, I was all the way in.” Pitts, who is now the managing co-director of that same organization, is among those leading the charge for a data center moratorium in Philadelphia.
- Coming up, why Patagonia could become the next data center hub, how semiconductors came through for China's trade numbers, and why the tariffs hitting Harley-Davidson are so high.
- Even as data centers entered the crosshairs of state moratoriums and public pushback in 2026, the number of planned and operating projects nearly tripled between March and August, according to a Construction Dive analysis of data from market intelligence company Cleanview.
- Today, projects over 1,000 megawatts are setting the benchmark, David Guarino, head of global data center and tower research at Green Street, a Newport, California-based commercial real estate data provider, told Construction Dive in April.